Isabella Thornton
As of May 6, 2025, the highly anticipated You Be the Judge: Crime & Punishment is streaming exclusively on Channel 5 and its official platform, 5 (formerly My5), available through both the website and app in the United Kingdom. If you’re in the US and don’t want to miss a single moment of this content, don’t worry—there’s a simple and secure way to watch it from anywhere. With the right tools, you can join the experience effortlessly and enjoy every moment as if you were tuning in from the UK.
How can I watch You Be the Judge: Crime & Punishment in the US on 5
To watch You Be the Judge: Crime & Punishment in the US, use Channel 5’s free streaming service, 5 (formerly My5). Connect to a UK server with a premium VPN , and stream the content easily as if you were located in the United Kingdom.
You Be the Judge: Crime & Punishment Synopsis
You Be the Judge: Crime & Punishment is a powerful factual documentary that puts the British public’s views on justice under the microscope. Anne Robinson leads viewers through a provocative social experiment that highlights the gap between public opinion and judicial decision-making. The programme reconstructs real-life sentencing hearings, focusing on murder, manslaughter, and death by dangerous driving. Audiences are encouraged to weigh in with their own verdicts, only to be confronted with the actual outcomes from the legal system. This show offers a rare behind-the-scenes look at the sentencing process—a stage of trial juries never witness. It also explores the complex balance between aggravating and mitigating factors in sentencing. At its core, the documentary asks: is Britain being too soft on crime?
When does You Be the Judge: Crime & Punishment premiere?
You Be the Judge: Crime & Punishment premieres on Tuesday, May 6, 2025, at 9:00 PM on 5 HD (Channel 5). The programme runs until 10:30 PM and includes subtitles for accessibility.
You Be the Judge: Crime & Punishment Cast
- Anne Robinson – Presenter
The iconic journalist and broadcaster brings her signature sharpness to this legal experiment, guiding the audience through each emotional and ethical dilemma. - Elliot Reed – Executive Producer
With a background in thought-provoking television, Reed ensures the programme remains both engaging and socially relevant. - Gillian Bancroft – Director
Bancroft’s direction brings clarity and emotional weight to complex legal issues, expertly shaping the documentary’s narrative structure.
Do viewers get to participate in judging the cases?
Yes, viewers are encouraged to consider how they would sentence the offenders before the real verdicts are revealed.
Why is the show significant?
It highlights the disconnect between public opinion and judicial outcomes, especially as 71% of UK citizens think sentences are too lenient.
Can I watch You Be the Judge: Crime & Punishment in the US?
You can watch You Be the Judge: Crime & Punishment on Channel 5’s streaming platform, 5 (formerly My5), from the US by using a reliable VPN, Smart DNS, or proxy service. These tools disguise your IP address to make it appear as if you’re browsing from the UK, giving you seamless and unrestricted access to the content.
Is there a legal way to watch “You Be the Judge: Crime & Punishment” online for free?
Yes, you can stream “You Be the Judge: Crime & Punishment” for free on Channel 5’s streaming service, 5, which includes ads and is available within the UK.
You Be the Judge: Crime & Punishment Trailer
You Be the Judge: Crime & Punishment FAQ
- Can I watch Channel 5 abroad?
Yes, you can stream Channel 5 abroad by using a VPN, which allows you to connect to a UK server and unlock region-restricted content. - Is You Be the Judge: Crime & Punishment a series or a special?
It’s a one-off documentary special that reconstructs four real criminal sentencing cases in one single airing. - Do I need an account to watch Channel 5 online?
Yes, users must register for a free 5 account to stream Channel 5 content online. - Who presents You Be the Judge: Crime & Punishment?
The programme is presented by Anne Robinson, known for her bold style and past work on Watchdog and The Weakest Link. - How long is the programme?
It runs for 90 minutes, ending at 10:30 PM BST. - Is You Be the Judge: Crime & Punishment available on demand?
Yes, it will be available to stream on 5 (formerly My5), Channel 5’s official on-demand platform.
You May Also Check This Out
When you make a purchase through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission at no additional cost to you. Learn more about how this works.
GIPHY App Key not set. Please check settings