Isabella Thornton
Here’s everything you need to know about Hallmark’s festive competition series Finding Mr. Christmas Season 2 (2025) — from its premiere date and streaming details to the full episode lineup, hosts and judges, and the complete contestants list. Plus, you’ll find a simple step-by-step guide on how to watch it online from outside the US without any interruptions.
Got questions about streaming or episode availability? Drop them in the comments below, and I’ll help you get started so you can enjoy this heartwarming holiday competition hassle-free.
How can I watch Finding Mr. Christmas Season 2 outside the US on Hallmark+?
To watch Finding Mr. Christmas Season 2 (2025) outside the US, use a reliable VPN to bypass geo-restrictions and access American streaming platforms. Simply connect to a US server and start streaming on the Hallmark Channel, Hallmark+, or supported live TV services. You can also watch through platforms like Hulu + Live TV, DirecTV Stream, Philo, FuboTV, Frndly TV, Sling TV (with the Lifestyle Extra add-on), YouTube TV, Spectrum TV, and Vidgo for full access to every episode in HD quality.
- Subscribe to NordVPN
- Install the VPN app on your device.
- Connect to a US-based server.
- Open Hallmark+ website or launch its app, then log in.
- You can watch Finding Mr. Christmas Season 2 outside the US.
PS: Users of other live streaming services – TV providers can also apply the same method.
Finding Mr. Christmas Season 2 Plot
In Finding Mr. Christmas Season 2, ten contestants compete for the ultimate Hallmark dream — a starring role in a Countdown to Christmas movie. With Jonathan Bennett hosting and Melissa Peterman returning as the head judge, the show combines lighthearted competition with genuine emotion. Each episode pushes the men to express authenticity, warmth, and star quality through fun and festive challenges. From snowball skits to heartfelt monologues, every task reveals who truly embodies the spirit of a Hallmark hero. As the season progresses, bonds form, rivalries heat up, and the magic of Christmas becomes the stage for one man’s Hollywood beginning.
When does Finding Mr. Christmas Season 2 premiere?
The second season of Finding Mr. Christmas premieres on October 27, 2025, on the Hallmark Channel, with full streaming access available on Hallmark+ the following day.
Host and Judges:
- Jonathan Bennett – Host and Executive Producer; brings his signature warmth and humor to guide the contestants through each challenge.
- Melissa Peterman – Lead Judge; known for her witty insight and heart, she helps decide who has what it takes to be Hallmark’s next leading man.
- Janel Parrish – Guest Judge; appears in special episodes to mentor contestants during romantic and performance-based tasks.
- Adam Cohen, Trish Gold, Ben Roy, Allison Schermerhorn, Cara Tapper, Joanna Vernetti – Executive producers responsible for crafting this magical holiday competition.
Contestants:
- Angel Garet (38) – From Charlotte, North Carolina, Angel works as a model, actor, and bartender. His charisma and positive energy make him a standout in the competition.
- Craig Geoghan (33) – Hailing from Lake Ronkonkoma, New York, Craig is a personal trainer and actor who brings heart and determination to every challenge.
- Davey Fisher (34) – Based in Lake Tahoe, Nevada, Davey is a commercial model and actor known for his professionalism and charm — he’s even worked as Chris Hemsworth’s body double.
- Drake Kuyper (27) – From Denver, Colorado, Drake is a model and social media manager with confidence and style that light up the screen.
- Gabriel Thaxton (32) – A model from Laramie, Wyoming, Gabriel’s easygoing personality and heartfelt connection to family life make him one to watch.
- Jake Schum (36) – A former NFL player from Lake View, New York, Jake is stepping into acting for the first time, bringing natural confidence and competitive spirit.
- Logan Shephard (30) – From Cincinnati, Ohio, Logan works as a server and photographer, combining creativity with an adventurous attitude.
- Marcus Brodie (32) – Representing Hamilton, Ohio, Marcus is both a model and actor, blending charm and stage presence with ease.
- Robbie Simpson (35) – A New York-based acting teacher, Robbie combines professional insight with humor and warmth, making him a natural favorite.
- Rustin Sailors (37) – From San Diego, California, Rustin is a musician whose artistic soul and charisma bring rhythm and originality to the show.
How many episodes does Finding Mr. Christmas Season 2 have?
The season features nine festive episodes.
Episode Guide:
- The Search for Mr. Christmas – October 27, 2025: The contestants meet for the first time and face their first festive challenge, reinventing Santa in creative ways.
- Reindeer Games – November 3, 2025: Teams compete to deliver gifts in a high-energy challenge and holiday photo shoot.
- Riding Into Romance – November 10, 2025: The men share personal holiday stories and film a cowboy-themed romantic scene.
- A Very Merry Talent Show – November 17, 2025: Contestants perform in a Christmas-themed showcase of humor, dance, and song.
- Christmas on Main Street – November 24, 2025: A holiday obstacle course tests their teamwork and festive flair.
- Holiday Hearts – December 1, 2025: Emotional acting challenges reveal their ability to bring heartfelt warmth to the screen.
- The Perfect Gift – December 8, 2025: The contestants reflect on their journeys and open up about personal growth.
- Love Under the Mistletoe – December 15, 2025: Romantic chemistry becomes the key to surviving this elimination round.
- Reunion – December 20, 2025: The finale crowns one man as Hallmark’s next leading man, ready to star in his own Christmas movie.
Where to Watch Finding Mr. Christmas Season 2 in the US
As of October 27, 2025, Finding Mr. Christmas Season 2 airs on the Hallmark Channel, bringing back the beloved holiday competition to TV screens. Viewers can start streaming it on Hallmark+ beginning the following day for on-demand access. In the United States, the show is also available to stream live on major platforms such as Hulu + Live TV, DirecTV, Philo, FuboTV, Frndly TV, Sling TV (with the Lifestyle Extra Bundle), YouTube TV, Spectrum TV, and Vidgo, offering multiple ways to enjoy every festive episode.
Can I download Finding Mr. Christmas Season 2 for offline viewing?
Yes, you can download Finding Mr. Christmas Season 2 for offline viewing on the Hallmark+ app. Downloads are available only within the app on mobile devices and may expire after 30 days or if your subscription ends.
On What Device Can I Watch Hallmark+
| Device Type | Supported Platforms |
|---|---|
| Smart TVs | Samsung (2018+), Sony (2019+), LG (webOS 4+), VIZIO Smart TVs |
| Streaming Devices | Roku, Amazon Fire TV, Fire Stick, Apple TV, Android TV, Google TV |
| Mobile Devices | iPhone & iPad (iOS 13+), Android phones & tablets (Android 5.0+) |
| Computers | Windows PC and Mac via web browsers (Chrome, Safari, Edge) |
| Casting | Chromecast support from iOS and Android devices |
Finding Mr. Christmas Season 2 Trailer
FAQs
- What is the format of the competition in Season 2?
Each episode features the contestants taking part in two types of challenges — one a festive “face-off” like snowman building or ski-slope stunts, and another where they must act or perform to show they have star quality. - What is the prize for the winner of Season 2?
The winner earns the title “Mr. Christmas” and is cast in a leading role in one of Hallmark’s upcoming holiday movies — a major break into the festive-film world. - Who are the host and lead judge for Season 2?
The host is Jonathan Bennett, and the lead judge is Melissa Peterman. They bring expertise and holiday-cheer charisma to guide the competition.
You May Also Check This Out
When you make a purchase through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission at no additional cost to you. Learn more about how this works.
GIPHY App Key not set. Please check settings